Everyone loves arguing about melee weapons:3 Here's an excerpt from J. Silver's book Paradoxes of Defense. What do you think has the greater advantage?

Everyone loves loves arguing arguing about about melee melee weapons:3 weapons:3 Here's Here's an an excerpt excerpt from from J. J. Silver's Silver's book book Paradoxes Paradoxes of of Defense. Defense. What What do do you you think think has has the the greater greater advantage?